Benefits and drawbacks of hybrid, hardwareassisted software raid. Hardware raid performs better in complex configurations also as processing in this system is handled by a dedicated raid controller rather than. Soft possibly the longest running battle in raid circles is which is faster, hardware raid or software raid. That is to say, it is hardware independent without needs to be tied to hardware vendors. An example of a hardware raid device would be one that connects to a scsi controller and presents the raid. Provided you have enough machine resources cpu, ram, bus speed, and a good disk controller as a general rule, software raid will outperform hardware raid if the underlying software raid is designed well. Reasons for using software raid versus a hardware raid setup. Plus, software raid permits users to reconfigure your arrays without being restricted by the hardware raid controller. A raid can be deployed using both software and hardware. I have scoured through articles written about tuning software and i have used linux software raid for over 10 years. Hardware redundant array of inexpensive disks raid and software raid are two main ways for setting up raid system. The raid can be implemented either using a special controller hardware raid, or by an operating system driver software raid. Windows software raid vs hardware raid ars technica. In the same time stability and performance of software raid is not as high as hardware.
Software vs hardware raid performance and cache usage. Can i use the jbod option on the raid card, or do i have to buy a normal sas controller for the zfs option. Thus, more space and speed can be used to read and write data. There is software raid available from microsoft in windows 10 called storage spaces. Software raid is usually recommended for low budget machines its a part of many linuxbased system, and its free of charge if you are not able to afford a good hardware raid. With software raid your data can be split across different enclosures for complete redundancy one can completely stop working and your data is still ok. But with budget favoring the software raid, those wanting optimum performance and efficiency of raid will have to go with the hardware raid. The decision between a discrete hardware based solution versus a software based solution boils down to how robust of a raid platform you are wanting to set up. Jul 07, 2009 a redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability.
Windows software raid and its rebranded version called storage spaces does not meet this last criteria, imo. The only point in using raid, is to handle a drive failure, without causing downtime. It is a way to virtualize multiple, independent hard disk drives into one or more arrays to improve performance, capacity and reliability. It just has a boot helper to go along with it in the bios. I personally avoid marvell integrated raid like the plague due to extremely poor performance worse by far than windows raid, but some of their actual hardware solutions are alright. Poweredge move from software raid to hardware raid controller. Aug 25, 2010 software raid means that the raid is handled by the general purpose os and hardware raid means that the raid is handled by a special purpose satasas controller card that runs its own os, cpu, memory, etc. Raid hardware vs raid software what is your best option. The core of a raid system is the controller, which plays an important role in distributing data to and from the hard drives that make up the raid array. Therefore both are susceptible to bugs in software.
Jan 23, 2012 software raid does not need raid hardware support and can be used on machines without raid options. Raid 1 vs backup and software raid 1 vs hardware raid 1 h. The performance of a software based array depends on the server cpu performance and load. What is the difference between a software and hardware raid. My experience with hardware and fake hardware raid is that as long as you stay with the same vendor, the raid metadata will be recognized ive seen this when moving drives between various hp, areca and lsi hardware raid controllers, and with intel, amd and even via hostraid i was pretty surprised when i connected a 250gb hard drive from some old amd desktop box to a hp g1 microserver, and. May 24, 2005 scott lowe responds to a techrepublic discussion and one members raid dilemma. Where that processing occurs can be important depending on the complexity of your raid setup. Software vs bios vs hardware raid ars technica openforum. So, if the disks in hardware raid have different capacities. Differences between hardware raid, hbas, and software raid. Software raid does its processing on the server motherboard.
Before raid was raid, software disk mirroring raid 1 was a huge profit generator for system vendors, who sold it as an addon to their operating systems. After many years of running software raid setups in linux ive never run into a bug that caused data loss. Aug 14, 2018 raid stands for redundant array of inexpensive disks. As the comments on my recent post apples new kickbutt file system showed, some folks cant believe that software raid could. But to appease the powers that be, i have explained the two below hardware raid is when you have a dedicated controller to do the work for you. My experience with hardware and fake hardware raid is that as long as you stay with the same vendor, the raid metadata will be recognized ive seen this when moving drives between various hp, areca and lsi hardware raid controllers, and with intel, amd and even via hostraid i was pretty surprised when i connected a 250gb hard drive from some old amd desktop box to a hp. Software raid virtually belongs to operating system. Hardware raid presents logical disks that are already configured to the system or the san, mirrored and ready to go. A hardware raid controller would be best, but the fakemotherboardneedsadriver raid is just one more thing to go wrong, and the less likely. So raid is kind of a method for improving the performance and reliability of your storage media by using multiple drives. Feb 28, 2018 raid redundant array of independent disks is one of the popular data storage virtualization technology.
Independent disks technology has grown from a server option to a data protection. Hardware raid is a form of raid redundant array of independent disks where processing is done on the motherboard or a separate raid card. Comparing hardware raid vs software raid setups deals with how the storage drives in a raid array connect to the motherboard in a server or pc, and the management of those drives. As the comments on my recent post apples new kickbutt file system showed, some folks cant believe that software raid. Jul 22, 2019 generally speaking, raid has socket limitation except for software raid. The terms hardware raid and software raid are very misleading as all raid controllers do raid using software. Whether software raid vs hardware raid is the one for you depends on what you need to do and how much you want to pay. The first thing i had to decide on was hardware versus software raid. It seems that no matter if you use a hardware or a software raid controller, you should expect to lose performance when youre duplicating every write, which makes sense. Lets start the hardware vs software raid battle with the hardware side. Beyond that, hardware raid usually has at least options for battery backed or newer capacitorflash based write caches.
We now want to add a raid controller so we can configure for hardware raid 10. In your situation, i would go with the software raid. Oct 30, 2015 while the intel raid controller blows the software raid out of the water on sequential reads, surprisingly the windows software raid was better in nearly every other respect. Software raid, as you might already know, is usually builtin on your os and unlike a hardware raid, you will need to spend a little extra on a controller card.
The linux kernel contains an md driver that allows the raid solution to be completely hardware independent. A hardware raid device connects to the scsi controller and presents the raid arrays as a single scsi drive. There are 2 types of raid controllers including hardwarebased and softwarebased. As mentioned previously, this technology is divided to several very popular and important raid levels where each.
Jun, 2016 comparing hardware raid vs software raid setups deals with how the storage drives in a raid array connect to the motherboard in a server or pc, and the management of those drives. Describe the differences between a hardware raid and a. Hardware raid is dedicated processing system, using controllers or raid cards to manage the raid configuration independently from the. Also included with most intelbased motherboards is a hardware raid. Favoring hardware raid over software raid comes from a time when hardware was just not powerful enough to handle software raid processing, along with all the other tasks that it was being used for. This is a method of improving the performance and reliability of your storage media by using multiple drives. Im planning a home media server using a node 804 case. The different options for combining the disks are referred to as raid levels. In the last couple of years, raid redundant array of. It presents a single disk per raid array to the host.
Hardware raid was the initial type of raid available, where a specially built raid controller handles the drives so that the processes are almost transparent to the host computer. Hardware raid will cost more, but it will also be free of software raid s. Difference between software raid and hardware raid in high level is presented in this video session. If you can handle your system being down, for a drive replacement, and worst case, a reinstall, then you dont need raid. Scott lowe responds to a techrepublic discussion and one members raid dilemma.
With hardware raid, because the processing work is done on a discrete controller card in the server or at the level of the storage subsystem, theres no added load to the server processor and buses. Differences and data protection this article explains what raid is, what storage spaces is, and the differences between storage spaces and raid. Configuration is still required, but that configuration takes place outside the system. That is what the thread was about, mainly, will raid 1 benefit enough to justify the extra risk and investment for a hw controller. We have a dell poweredge r420 that came from the factory with software raid. Imho, im a big fan of kernel developers non directly related to zfs, so i really prefere mdadm to hardware raid. Before raid was raid, software disk mirroring raid 1 was a huge profit generator for system vendors, who sold it as an addon to their.
Back then, the solution was to use a hardware raid card with a builtin processor that handled the raid calculations offline. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a special raid controller inserted in a fast pciexpress pcie slot in a motherboard. Windows raid vs intel rst vs raidz vs hardware raid. Passthrough software raid on hardware raid controller. Hardware vs software raid the core of a raid system is the controller, which plays an important role in distributing data to and from the hard drives that make up the raid array. For hardware raid, that cpu can be in a disk array or in a raid controller. Software vs hardware raid a redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability.
When running basic io tests ddoflagdirect 5k to 100g files, hdparam t, etc. Solved hardware raid vs software lsi cards spiceworks. Here are some tips on raid levels and some feedback on the software vs. Recovery from a failed disk isnt likely to be an issue in either case. Turns out someone has done the analysis between them, and done a good job too. With todays faster cpus, software raid outperforms hardware raid. A redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability.
When your storage drives are directly connected to the servers motherboard without a raid controller, the raid configuration will be managed by the utility software in the operating system. We list the pros and cons of hardware vs software raid to help you decide which one is best for you. Raid is a method of combining multiple disk drives into a single entity in order to improve the overall performance and reliability of your system. Generally speaking, operating system treats raid as one disk. Dedicated hardware controller doing the processing vs. The motherboards supports inter enterprise rapid storage and i can also do software raid with windows server 2019 afaik. Hardware raid is dedicated processing system, using controllers or raid cards to manage the raid configuration independently from the operating system. Intel hardware raid vs microsoft storage spaces matts. Hardware raid is more common in windows server environments, wherein its advantages are better realized. The raid controller does not take processing power away from the disks it manages. Difference between hardware raid and software raid.
As the software for monitoring is standardized, you can use the same ways to monitor the health and performance of all your servers. Software raid is a newer type of raid and its cheaper than hardware raid,where no specialized hardware is needed, and the host computer is responsible for the drives. What is the difference between hardware and software raid. Software raid means that the raid is handled by the general purpose os and hardware raid means that the raid is handled by a special purpose satasas controller card that runs its own os, cpu, memory, etc. While the intel raid controller blows the software raid out of the water on sequential reads, surprisingly the windows software raid was better in nearly every other respect. It is used to improve disk io performance and reliability of your server or workstation. Raid stands for redundant array of inexpensive disks. What is the difference between hardware raid and software. With cheaper hardware raid you can also lose data if theres a power outage. You can easily move disks from a failed enclosure to a new one, and all your data is preserved. Jul 31, 2015 hardware raid hardware redundant array of independent disk. For software raid i used the linux kernel software raid functionality of a system running 64bit fedora 9.
Software raid is cheaper no additional hardware required so generally the question comes down to one of price vs. Hardware raid the hardware based array manages the raid subsystem independently from the host and presents to the host only a single disk per raid array. The number of sockets is determined by physical raid controller. As hivizman noted, if you require an enterprise level of reliability and resource allocation, then it is best served to go with a discrete hardware based platform. With hardware raid, if any part of the system fails such as the controller, enclosure or power supply you can lose all your data. But the real question is whether you should use a hardware raid solution or a software raid solution. It is still software but running on a dedicated controller.
Dec 21, 2005 for hardware raid, that cpu can be in a disk array or in a raid controller. Ive been hoping other people would post with some experience, because im in the middle of a decision and am leaning toward software but. Software raid works relying on the operating system. Hi everyone, im still new at this, so please forgive me if this is a basic question. Poweredge move from software raid to hardware raid. A question often asked in the server industry is, whats better.
Generally, hardware raid is faster, especially in writes. To compare software raid vs hardware raid, its also necessary to figure out what software raid is. I want a two drive fail recovery, raid 6 or what ever freenas uses for that. Software vs hardware raid performance and cache usage server. A simple way to describe software raid is that the raid task runs on the cpu of your computer system. Additionally, hardwareassisted software raid usually comes with a variety of drivers for the most popular operating systems, and therefore, is more os independent than pure software raid.
Apr 05, 2019 favoring hardware raid over software raid comes from a time when hardware was just not powerful enough to handle software raid processing, along with all the other tasks that it was being used for. The server i want comes with an adaptec 5805 hardware raid card. If anything they should be advised to increase ram and be done with it. Ive been reading a lot on raid controllerssetups and one thing that comes up a lot is how hardware controllers without cache offer the same performance as software raid. As part of my set of articles regarding raid, today i will be writing about different types of controllers. It combines multiple inexpensive, small disk drives into an array of disks in order to provide redundancy, lower latency maximizing the chanc. Under software raid, that configuration is performed in the. The software raid arrays are slower than the hardware raid because it uses the host system resources to run and maintain the raid array. If you remember in the first article i had touched on this subject a bit and now i will elaborate. However, windows 10 storage spaces and software raid dont have this limitation. Dell tells us that we cannot change it to hardware raid since it came new with software raid. Some software raid implementations include a piece of hardware, which might make the implementation seem like a hardware raid implementation, at first glance. I heard that is not possible with software firmware raid.
Software raid also works with cheaper ide disks as well as scsi disks. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a raid controller card inserted in a fast pciexpress pcie slot in a motherboard. Advantages of software raid being built into the os, software raid is costeffective as it requires no extra cost for the raid functionality except additional disk drives. Software raid is a newer type of raid where no specialized hardware is needed, and the host computer is responsible for the drives. It includes explanations on hardware raid, hardware assisted raid, software raid, and common raid types. Ive been hoping other people would post with some experience, because im in the middle of a decision and am leaning toward software but just basically fear the unknown. All you need to do is connect the drives and configure the raid level you want. Feb 27, 2019 provided you have enough machine resources cpu, ram, bus speed, and a good disk controller as a general rule, software raid will outperform hardware raid if the underlying software raid is designed well. There will likely be more advanced features, such as drives being hotswappable in case of failure. It is usually os agnostic, so volumes are not specific to an os file system like software raid.
399 1469 1067 305 991 255 709 598 953 1294 831 252 704 1469 967 1448 705 148 132 1119 930 755 1348 98 724 881 547 777 401 1141 923 957 176 713 972 702 611 433